The Brief Before the Brief

Every design project starts with a handful of questions the designer can’t answer for you. Answering them first changes everything that follows.

3 min read

You hire a designer. The first call goes well. Near the end, they ask what you want people to feel when they see your brand, and you say, “Professional. Modern. Clean, but not boring.”

They nod and write it down. Every designer has heard some version of it, and every designer knows how little it says.

Those words are real preferences. They describe taste, though, and taste can’t tell anyone who the work is for, what you stand for, or why a customer should choose you over the next option. A good designer will read between the lines. What they’re reading between is a gap, and each designer fills it with their own best guess.

So the first round comes back. It’s handsome. You can’t say why it isn’t right, only that it doesn’t feel like you. Round two shifts the colors. Round three changes the typeface. By round four everyone is a little tired, and nobody has mentioned the question that sat underneath all of it from the start.

Here’s what happens in those revision rounds: the decisions finally get made. They get made slowly, one reaction at a time, usually while the clock is running.

You discover you want to sound warmer than your competitors by reading a headline that sounds colder. You learn who your customer is by noticing who the draft was clearly written for, and it wasn’t them. The project turns into a very expensive way to find out what you think.

A brief is meant to prevent that, and a good one does. But a brief is only as clear as the thinking behind it. The form asks for audience, tone and competitors, and if those answers are still forming, the brief records the uncertainty and passes it along. Designers call it a vague brief. Often it’s an accurate one.

The projects that go differently tend to share one trait. The people commissioning them had already settled a few things: who they’re talking to, what they believe, how they want to sound, where they sit among the alternatives. None of it was elaborate. It was simply chosen. The designer’s first question got a real answer, and the hours that would have gone to guessing went to craft instead. Feedback got sharper too, because there was something to measure the work against besides a feeling.

Design gives brand decisions a form. When those decisions are still unresolved, the creative process has to do two jobs at once.

There’s a small test hiding in all of this: could you tell a stranger what your business stands for in a minute, and would the answer hold tomorrow? When it does, the brief has something solid to build on. When it doesn’t, that’s usually where the project actually begins.

Design is where decisions become visible. When those decisions are clear, creative exploration has somewhere meaningful to begin.


Build your Brand Blueprint →